Pennsylvania
Cheapest ACA plans in Carlisle, Pennsylvania for 2026
Plan year 2026, last refreshed 2026-04-19T08:08:55.462Z.
Carlisle is in Cumberland County, Pennsylvania. 6 carriers sell 2026 ACA plans on Pennie for residents of Cumberland County, and the cheapest Bronze plan a 40-year-old can enroll in starts at $478/month before any subsidy. Carriers are licensed and rated at the county level, so the plans below cover everyone in Cumberland County, including Carlisle.
Cheapest plans by metal tier
Lowest 2026 monthly premium for a single 40-year-old in Carlisle (Cumberland County), on-exchange, before any subsidy. Per-age figures derived from the CMS QHP Landscape file using the HHS standardized age-rating curve (45 CFR 147.102).
| Tier | Cheapest age 40 monthly | Plans in Cumberland County |
|---|---|---|
| Catastrophic | $402 | 3 |
| Bronze | $478 | 6 |
| Expanded Bronze | $503 | 17 |
| Gold | $681 | 35 |
| Silver | $789 | 17 |
The actual cheapest Bronze plan in Carlisle
Capital Advantage Assurance Company Bronze Capital Advantage PPO 9000/0/75
$478/moFor a family of four (two 40-year-olds and two kids under 14): Capital Advantage Assurance Company Bronze Capital Advantage PPO 9000/0/75 at $1,528/month before subsidies.
Carriers selling 2026 plans in Carlisle
6 carriers sell 2026 plans on Pennie for Cumberland County residents; 1 additional carrier offers off-exchange-only plans (not subsidy-eligible). 102 plans total in Cumberland County.
| Carrier | On-exchange plans |
|---|---|
| Highmark Inc. | 28 |
| Capital Advantage Assurance Company | 17 |
| Ambetter | 12 |
| Geisinger Health Plan | 11 |
| UPMC Health Options, Inc. | 6 |
| Geisinger Quality Options | 4 |
Also selling off-exchange only
These carriers sell plans directly (not through Pennie). Off-exchange plans are not eligible for federal APTC or state subsidies.
| Carrier | Off-exchange plans |
|---|---|
| Keystone Health Plan Central | 1 |
What you'll actually pay in Carlisle
Estimated monthly net premium for the cheapest Bronze plan above ($478/mo before subsidy) on Pennie, after federal APTC. APTC is computed against the Cumberland Countybenchmark Silver per 26 USC §36B. Approximate; exact net varies by plan's EHB% and child-rate structure.
Single 40-year-old
| Annual income | FPL % | Federal APTC | Cheapest Bronze net |
|---|---|---|---|
| $25,000 | 160% | $729/mo | $0/mo |
| $40,000 | 256% | $539/mo | $0/mo |
| $60,000 | 383% | $328/mo | $150/mo |
| $100,000 | 639% | — | $478/mo |
Family of 4 (two 40-year-olds, two children)
| Annual income | FPL % | Federal APTC | Cheapest Bronze net |
|---|---|---|---|
| $40,000 | 124% | — | Medicaid likely |
| $80,000 | 249% | $2,081/mo | $0/mo |
| $130,000 | 404% | — | $1,528/mo |
| $200,000 | 622% | — | $1,528/mo |
FPL = Federal Poverty Level. APTC = Advance Premium Tax Credit (the federal subsidy). Off-exchange and Catastrophic plans are not APTC-eligible. Enter your real income on the home page to see plan-specific net premium with the per-plan EHB-percent cap applied.
Frequently asked questions
What is the cheapest ACA plan in Carlisle, Pennsylvania for 2026?
The cheapest Bronze plan a 40-year-old can enroll in is Capital Advantage Assurance Company Bronze Capital Advantage PPO 9000/0/75 at $478 per month before subsidies. Plans sell through Pennie. Carlisle is in Cumberland County, Pennsylvania; carriers are licensed and rated at the county level. Data refreshed 2026-04-19T08:08:55.462Z.
How does Carlisle's 2026 ACA pricing compare to other Pennsylvania cities?
Cheapest Bronze for a 40-year-old in Carlisle is $478 per month before subsidies. For comparison: Philadelphia at $297/mo; Pittsburgh at $308/mo; Erie at $308/mo. Different cities can have different cheapest plans because plans are sold per county and carrier participation varies by jurisdiction.
Why does Pennsylvania have its own marketplace instead of HealthCare.gov?
Pennsylvania ran on HealthCare.gov through 2020, then launched Pennie as a state-based exchange for plan year 2021 under Act 42 of 2019. Running its own exchange lets Pennsylvania keep user-fee savings in-state, which funds the Pennsylvania Reinsurance Program.
What is the Pennsylvania Reinsurance Program and does it lower my 2026 premium?
Yes, indirectly. Since 2021, Pennie has run a §1332 waiver reinsurance program that reimburses carriers for a share of high-cost claims, historically reducing gross individual-market premiums by about 5%. You do not apply for it; the savings are already baked into premiums posted on Pennie.
Does Pennsylvania have a state premium subsidy on top of the federal APTC?
Not in 2026. The state legislature authorized a State Health Insurance Exchange Affordability Program in the 2024-2025 budget, but it has not been funded. Pennie enrollees rely on federal Advance Premium Tax Credits only, and the enhanced (ARPA/IRA) credits expired at the end of 2025.
More Pennsylvania pricing
- Statewide Pennsylvania pricing and metal tiers
- Philadelphia pricingcheapest Bronze $297/mo
- Pittsburgh pricingcheapest Bronze $308/mo
- Erie pricingcheapest Bronze $308/mo
Sources
- Pennie for SBE enrollment, OEP dates, and the Pennsylvania Reinsurance Program impact.
- Pennsylvania Insurance Department: ACA 2026 Rates for approved PY2026 rate changes and carrier-level tobacco loads.
- Pennie Agency: Final Enrollment Deadline Extension for the OEP extension to January 31, 2026.
- Act 42 of 2019: Insurance Exchange Authority Act for Pennie statutory basis and the 2021 FFM-to-SBE transition.
Plan year 2026, last refreshed 2026-04-19T08:08:55.462Z. Full pricing pipeline + regulatory references at methodology; ACA terminology in the glossary.